A difficult legacy

by Karl-Heinz Meier-Braun

The new Poland (Issue III/2021)


The entrance portal of the Linden Museum in Stuttgart. Photo: Harald Voelkl/Linden Museum Stuttgart

Recently, the phrase “Stop! Difficult legacy!” has appeared on the steps to the entrance of the Linden Museum in Stuttgart. An information board explains that even the entrance to the museum is a symbol of Germany’s colonial past. Hewn in stone above the portico is a clichéd depiction of two figures, presumably African and New Guinean, with broad noses and exaggerated lips. They are lit up by a pink beam, literally putting a spotlight on the building’s colonial past.

Under the direction of Inés de Castro, the Linden Museum has already been critically assessing its past for several years now. In this respect, its new exhibition is an important step and does not even stop at its namesake, Karl Graf von Linden (1838-1910), who managed the museum’s fortunes during the German colonial era and whose name was given to the new building on Hegelplatz in 1911. His activities have since been questioned in the workshop exhibition, in particular, his “collection” of many thousands of objects from colonial Germany and its “protectorates”. Next to his portrait, the museum poses critical questions: Did he receive stolen goods? Was he a thief?  A conservator? A patron of science? A wrecker of cultural artefacts?

With this fresh outlook, the Linden Museum traces a path back through its own past but also the urban and rural history of postcolonial issues. In doing so, it contributes to the field of provenance research which is still in its infancy in Germany. The exhibition reviews fascinating biographies and the organisation of colonialism from the German Empire to National Socialism is put on display.

“For the first time in this form, the sinister chapter of ethnographic shows, which reached their heyday between 1870 and 1940, is presented with a focus on Stuttgart.”

The section on “Colonialism and Violence” takes a look at the Boxer Rebellion in the German protectorate of China, in which hundreds of soldiers from Wurttemberg took part. The module “Everyday Culture” expands the visitor’s view of the phenomena of colonialism in everyday situations. For example, the exhibition is a reminder that the first major ethnography show – or “people’s zoo” – took place in Stuttgart in 1928 after the First World War, drawing a public of 200,000 people. For the first time in this form, the sinister chapter of ethnographic shows, which reached their heyday between 1870 and 1940, is presented with a focus on Stuttgart. On a record day in 1894, 28,000 people flocked to see the “Dinka Ethnography Show”, to look at people displayed like animals in a zoo. Pejorative attributions and racist and sexist terms have been masked to prevent their further usage.

The exhibition is also much more than just a documentation of historical material because it spans an arc to present-day racism. Visitors are repeatedly challenged to ask themselves questions and examine language and imagery. This includes the question of which name and purpose the museum should have in future. An exhibition might therefore set off a process of coming to terms with Germany’s colonial past and, in doing so, provide a role model for other museums and institutions.

similar articles

Taboo (Topic: Taboo)

“All cultures ban incest”

in conversation with Caroline Eliacheff

Psychoanalyst Caroline Eliacheff talks about our enduring taboos and those which disappear over time.


The new Poland (Topic: Poland)

“Our trauma has a million faces”

in conversation with Joanna Bator

The writer Joanna Bator is one of the most important voices of contemporary Polish literature. Her new novel is about angry women and women and deep psychological wounds. Is that coincidence or a statement?


The new Poland (Books)

At the paper mill

By Jennifer Dummer

In his new graphic novel, Guy Delisle illustrates the summer job he once had in a Canadian paper and pulp factory. 


Are we running out of water? (Topic: Are we running out of water?)

I am the river

by Vanessa Ellingham

New Zealand is struggling with bursting sewage pipes and contaminated drinking water. Now the indigenous population is to collaborate on solutions


The new Poland (Topic: Poland)

The Polish lesson

by Piotr Pacewicz

The government is remodelling the country. Many people in Poland are protesting against the changes. But why does the opposition remain so weak?


Talking about a revolution (Topic: Resistance)

“We are living in an age of extinction”

in conversation with Naomi Klein

The system critic Naomi Klein explains why she still has a glimmer of hope, despite the climate crisis.